Troy’s Hidden Waters
An Urban History of the Poestenkill and Its Forgotten Infrastructure
The Poestenkill carved this city long before it was built—its course shaping foundations, factories, and floodplains. Though hidden now beneath pavement and stone, the creek has never stopped flowing.
The Poestenkill begins high on the Rensselaer Plateau, fed by the cold waters of Dyken Pond in the hills of Grafton, New York. From there, it runs west, falling steadily through wooded hollows, shale shelves, and low cascades, carving its way toward the Hudson River. It isn’t a wide creek, but it moves with purpose, cutting through shale and slope as if following an older logic.
By the time it enters the city’s edge, the stream has earned its name. Dutch settlers recorded it as Poesten Kill, “foaming creek.” The term “kill” is a Dutch word for stream, and “Poesten” is thought to refer to Jan Barentsen Wemp, a 17th-century settler sometimes nicknamed “Poest.” While the exact origin isn’t fully confirmed, the association has been widely accepted in local histories. Regardless of etymology, the name fits the current: restless, swift, and often foaming through tight channels. *
The creek remains visible for a time, dipping in and out of view through a ravine that snakes westward toward downtown. Gradually, its course disappears beneath the foundations and narrow grids of Troy. The creek doesn’t end. It is absorbed, channeled into culverts, shadowed by pavement, and threaded beneath the city’s surface like forgotten infrastructure.
Near Linden Avenue, the terrain suddenly drops in a way that feels abrupt, almost accidental. It isn’t a park or an excavation site. It’s the mouth of the Poestenkill Gorge, steep, wooded, and sharply cut. Glacial runoff once screamed through here at the end of the last Ice Age, and for centuries since, the creek has deepened that path. Even now, the slopes are lined with fallen timbers and fern, with stone walls hidden under vines, old sluices and retaining channels that once directed water toward textile mills and foundries. This landscape didn’t bend easily. It was blasted, bricked, and carved to fit the needs of a rising industrial city.
One of the gorge’s best-known features is a shadowed plunge pool locals have long referred to as Mary’s Hole. The water stays cold year-round and dark in summer, the kind of place that gathers stories. While not officially marked or documented in city records, the name endures in oral tradition. Generations of Troy residents have passed down accounts of drownings, strange currents, and sudden disappearances. There is no signage, no fencing. Only water tumbling in from upstream, rounding the stone, hour by hour.
In heavy spring runoff, the Poestenkill fills the gorge with sound. It rushes through the natural funnel, sending echoes up the walls, past ledges where old handrails once clung to the stone. The air near the base hangs damp and green. Even with no rain in the forecast, it always feels like the edge of a storm.
From there, the Poestenkill changes. Within a few blocks, it drops out of sight, drawn into the city’s oldest stormwater system. In the late 19th century, as Troy grew and runoff increased, engineers constructed a stone-arched culvert beneath Spring Avenue. Built from locally quarried limestone, the tunnel remains one of the region’s most enduring pieces of infrastructure. It was crafted for resilience: broad arches, well-set keystones, and footings sunk deep into bedrock. Designed to last.
Stand near the grate today and you’ll feel the change in the air, a drop in temperature, the smell of wet iron and moss. When the creek runs high, the tunnel vibrates with the rush of water. Sound bounces off the stone vault, low and steady. Glimpses of motion flicker behind the bars, light skimming the surface as it twists through the passage. The entrance is sealed, but the noise never stops. It’s a reminder: the creek still moves beneath the city.
Once it passes underground, the Poestenkill enters a matrix. Its path from the gorge to the Hudson threads through old culverts, concrete channels, and hand-laid brick tunnels. It detours around utilities, slips beneath railbeds, and winds under alleys and backlots. Some passages date to the 1800s. Others were added during flood-control projects in the 20th century. The system wasn’t built all at once, it was layered. Some of it exists only in fragments: an engineer’s sketch in the archives, a surveyor’s note, a faded photo from a maintenance crawl. The rest survives in memory, passed between city crews, learned by walking the lines in rubber boots.
Below Congress and Jefferson Streets, the culvert walls are still limestone. Chisel marks run the length of some blocks, barely visible now. Farther downstream, the channel narrows. The ceiling rusts with streaks of iron. The air grows still. In dry months, the flow nearly vanishes. After rain, it returns with force, dragging with it leaves, silt, and runoff.
Sometimes the creek surfaces in the middle of the street. Locals know which manholes mist after a storm, which backyards flood first, which basements begin to groan after two days of rain. The water finds its way through the seams, along Fourth, Monroe, and Adams, where old culverts intersect with storm drains and aging sewer lines. These are convergence points, designed for a different era, now stressed by runoff the system was never meant to handle. You can hear it in the way the water moves under the laundromat on Fourth, or how it rushes beneath a cracked sidewalk on Monroe. The signs don’t call attention to themselves, but they’re always there.
Eventually, the Poestenkill returns. Behind a chain-link fence on Front Street, it emerges. The outfall is cut into the hillside, concrete, utilitarian, stained from decades of stormwater. There is no signage, no overlook. The water crashes through and spills over stone. A short tumble, then calm. Then the Hudson.
In all, the final two miles of the Poestenkill are buried. The city grew up around the water, then over it. The creek remains. During floods, during snowmelt, during quiet summer nights when the tunnels echo, it continues along the route it carved long before zoning maps and sidewalk grids.
Walk Troy with this knowledge and the streets change shape. The dips in the grade. The sudden turns. The lots built on slant. The city follows the creek, even when it forgets. Beneath everything, the pavement, the foundations, the years of human effort, runs a memory in water. The Poestenkill is still moving.
The next time you drive the grid of Collar City streets, remember how the Poestenkill shaped the city. The line it cuts still guides the shape of things, the tilt of a porch, the pattern of a floodplain, the cold edge of a foundation wall. Where water once ran, it often runs again. You can pave over it. You can reroute it. But it leaves a mark. And if you pay attention, you’ll see where the land still follows its lead.
* As with many place names of early colonial origin, the exact etymology of “Poestenkill” is subject to interpretation. While one common explanation attributes the name to the Dutch words for “foaming creek” or to the nickname of early settler Jan Barentsen Wemp (“Poest”), other variations and folk explanations persist. The true origin may never be fully verified, and readers should consider this name as part of a broader and often imprecise historical tradition of naming shaped by language, memory, and local usage.
Discover Restoration Obscura’s Field Guide to the Night by John Bulmer
A hauntingly beautiful journey through how darkness has shaped human history, culture, and memory, from wartime blackouts and Cold War surveillance to ancient skywatchers and light‑polluted nights. Part memoir, part cultural history, this immersive field guide challenges us to step out of the glow and reconnect with what the night still has to teach.
📚 Paperback ($14.99) / Kindle ($9.99) | 368 pages | Published June 1, 2025 | ISBN 979‑8218702731 | Restoration Obscura Press
Available worldwide on Amazon (Prime eligible)
About Restoration Obscura
Restoration Obscura is where overlooked history gets another shot at being seen, heard, and understood. Through long-form storytelling, archival research, and photographic restoration, we recover the forgotten chapters—the ones buried in basements, fading in family albums, or sealed behind locked doors.
The name nods to the camera obscura, an early photographic device that captured light in a darkened chamber. Restoration Obscura flips that idea, pulling stories out of darkness and casting light on what history left behind.
This project uncovers what textbooks miss: Cold War secrets, vanished neighborhoods, wartime experiments, strange ruins, lost towns, and the people tied to them. Each episode, article, or image rebuilds a fractured past and brings it back into focus, one story at a time.
If you believe memory is worth preserving, if you’ve ever felt something standing at the edge of a ruin or holding an old photograph, this space is for you.
Subscribe to support independent, reader-funded storytelling: www.restorationobscura.com
🎧 The Restoration Obscura Field Guide Podcast is streaming now on all major streaming platforms.
Every photo has a story. And every story connects us.
© 2025 John Bulmer Media & Restoration Obscura. All rights reserved. Educational use only.
Permissions Statement
Restoration Obscura may not hold copyright for all images featured in its archives or publications. For uses beyond educational or non-commercial purposes, please contact the institution or original source that provided the image.